Study reveals majority of US prisoners were previously victims of violent crime
A new study by Just Safe reveals that 84% of people who have been incarcerated in the US were victims of violent crime before their first arrest, highlighting the need for trauma-informed justice policies.
By Malik Popov ·

A significant new study indicates that most individuals who have served time in American prisons or jails were themselves victims of violent crime before their initial incarceration. Researchers from Just Safe, a non-profit organization dedicated to victims' advocacy, determined that 84 percent of people with a history of incarceration reported being assaulted, shot, or stabbed prior to their first entry into the justice system.
The findings are based on a nationally representative survey involving 20,000 Americans. Among the respondents who had been incarcerated, half reported being hurt by a caregiver during their childhood. Additionally, one-third of these individuals identified as victims of sexual or intimate partner violence, highlighting a widespread pattern of trauma before formal legal intervention.
Lenore Anderson, the president of Just Safe in Oakland, California, stated that this research aims to encourage the public and elected officials to reconsider the political narrative surrounding crime. She argued that the focus should shift away from purely punitive measures toward strengthening resources for trauma recovery. Anderson emphasized the importance of viewing the collateral consequences of victimization, asking what happened to individuals and whether they received adequate support.
The report details how individuals who experience harm but do not receive trauma recovery services often cope with their pain. Some turn to drugs and alcohol, while others may replicate the violence they endured by hurting others. These coping mechanisms can lead to a cycle of reentry into the justice system and increase the risk of future violence, according to the study's authors.
Jemaine Hunter, who grew up in Fresno, California, shared his personal experience as an example of these trends. As a child and young teenager, he faced violence from family members and frequently got into fights in his neighborhood. By age thirteen, he was involved in physical confrontations with local young men. Hunter recalled that he felt like a victim in nearly every situation, noting that he was often robbed or lost fights, yet it was not his fault that these events occurred.
Hunter also witnessed numerous shootings in his community, which influenced his decision to keep a gun for protection. He described feeling the need to be ready to use a firearm at all times to avoid becoming a victim. At the age of 24, after multiple stints in juvenile detention, he was convicted of attempted murder and sentenced to 34 years to life. He served 23 years in California prisons, including San Quentin, before his release in December 2025.
Currently, Hunter works as a counselor for Sunset Youth Services, a San Francisco-based non-profit that assists young people on probation or with repeated arrests. During his time in San Quentin, he co-founded Arms Down, a national first for a support group specifically for individuals convicted of gun offenses. He observed that many inmates had histories of being jumped or abused, often leading them to join gangs and carry firearms to feel safe.
The report recommends specific actions to break the cycle of violence, such as training teachers, nurses, and first responders to refer victims to assistance services. It also suggests that municipalities should invest more in trauma recovery and reduce bureaucratic barriers to victims' compensation. Anderson stated that true public safety requires identifying what stops the cycle, which differs from the current criminal justice approach by focusing on accountability and underlying drivers.
Hunter has been teaching the Arms Down curriculum to youth in San Francisco who carry guns, many of whom have experienced violence or lost friends to it. He aims to provide the mentorship and support he lacked during his teenage years. He expressed hope that the model developed by Sunset Youth Services could be replicated in cities across the country to better serve young people navigating trauma.
The study underscores the connection between early victimization and later incarceration. By addressing the root causes of trauma, society may be better equipped to prevent future cycles of violence and support individuals in the justice system.






