Florida City Commissioner Post Settled by Coin Toss After Vote Deadlock
Jennifer Lagner was elected Atlantic Beach city commissioner after a coin flip broke a tie with Lisa Herrold following exhaustive recounts in Duval County.
By Riya Zielinski ·

Jennifer Lagner secured the position of city commissioner for Seat 4 in Atlantic Beach, Florida, through a coin toss after a final recount resulted in a perfect tie with her opponent, Lisa Herrold. The unusual resolution followed a series of voting verifications that left both candidates with identical tallies, triggering a specific local rule for determining a winner in the event of a deadlock.
According to reports from the New York Post, the final count stood at 3,162 votes for each candidate. This number was established after Jerry Holland, the Supervisor of Elections for Duval County, ordered both a manual recount and a machine recount. Despite these rigorous checks, the vote remained evenly split, necessitating the implementation of the city's unique tiebreaker procedure.
The tiebreaker took place last week and involved a series of three coin flips. Under the established rules, each candidate was given the opportunity to call the outcome of the coin's landing. The first candidate to successfully win two of the three flips would be declared the victor. The process was designed to be fair, allowing both Lagner and Herrold an equal chance to determine the final result through chance.
Lisa Herrold chose to make the first call in the sequence. She predicted that the coin would land on heads, but it instead landed on tails. This initial miss gave Jennifer Lagner a 1-0 lead in the coin toss contest. The tension of the moment was palpable as the outcome of the election hinged on the next few seconds of the process.
Lagner took her turn next and accurately predicted that the coin would land on heads. This correct call secured her the second point, bringing her total to two wins and officially ending the contest. With the coin toss concluded, Lagner was declared the winner of the election and the new commissioner for the district.
In the aftermath of the decision, Lagner expressed her gratitude and surprise at the outcome. She told a local news outlet, 'This shows how great and free our country is.' On her personal Facebook page, she wrote that she was honored to serve as the next City Commissioner. She described the coin toss as an 'unexpected and unforgettable way to bring an election to a close' and thanked Jerry Holland and his team for their work throughout the process.
Herrold also addressed the situation with a sense of community spirit. She noted that she and Lagner have been part of the local community for many years. 'It was meant to be .. We’re going to look back at this and realize how unbelievable this was,' Herrold said in an interview with a local outlet. Her comments reflected a gracious acceptance of the unconventional method used to resolve the race.
Supervisor of Elections Jerry Holland emphasized the significance of the event in the context of local democracy. He remarked that the situation was 'remarkable' and highlighted the broader implication that every single vote matters. 'One vote can make a difference,' Holland added, reinforcing the importance of participation in the electoral process even when the margins are extremely narrow.
This incident is not the first time that an election in Duval County has been resolved through an unconventional method. In 2014, a tie in the Neptune Beach City Council race between Rory Diamond and Richard Arthur was broken by having the candidates choose from a series of numbered ping pong balls. Arthur won that contest after selecting the ball with the higher number. The Atlantic Beach election adds another chapter to the county's history of unique tiebreakers.
As of the time of reporting, Lagner, Herrold, and the office of the Duval County Supervisor of Elections had not immediately responded to requests for further comment from Fox News Digital. The report was contributed to by Reuters, providing additional context on the local political developments in the region.
More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?






