Surgeon demands criminal probe into NHS Grampian after 19 surgical deaths
A senior surgeon has urged for a criminal investigation into a Scottish hospital after an expert report confirmed 19 avoidable surgical deaths, sparking debate in the Scottish Parliament.
By Riya Zielinski ·

A senior surgeon at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary has called for a criminal investigation into the health board that manages the hospital, citing at least 19 patient deaths resulting from avoidable surgical complications. Dr Mohammed Habib, a consultant at the facility, stated that he had raised concerns about liver and pancreatic surgery units repeatedly since 2021. He believes that dozens of patients may have died unnecessarily due to systemic issues within the department.
Habib alleged that senior officials at NHS Grampian failed to act swiftly enough on his reports and those of a second whistleblower. The health board eventually commissioned an expert report to examine these claims. The findings, published by Habib’s solicitor Aamer Anwar on Thursday, confirmed that 19 patients died from serious adverse events caused by surgery between 2015 and 2021. Habib is calling for the police to investigate the cases as corporate homicide.
The findings were discussed at the Scottish Parliament later on Thursday. First Minister John Swinney described the disclosures as of the gravest concern, noting that the NHS has a legal duty to provide the best possible care and investigate safety failures. However, he rejected the demand from Scottish Labour leader Michael Marra for a specific criminal inquiry into the systemic failures. Marra argued that the families of the deceased deserve answers and justice. Swinney maintained that recent decisions to demand leadership changes and urgent reforms would produce the necessary improvements.
Laura Skaife-Knight, the chief executive of NHS Grampian, acknowledged the serious allegations. She stated that a thorough investigation had already taken place, with some elements still ongoing. The board promised to consider any new evidence carefully and to continue responding through appropriate clinical, governance, and legal processes. She emphasized that patient safety remains the highest priority and that the duty of candour processes are being followed to communicate with affected families.
External experts who reviewed the data in 2022 found that the death rate in the relevant surgery units at Aberdeen reached as high as 18% between 2017 and 2020. This is significantly higher than the national average of 2% to 3% for similar procedures, depending on patient conditions. Despite these findings, Habib noted that the unit continued operating on patients. He subsequently flagged four additional deaths that occurred during or after surgery following the completion of that expert report.
In March 2026, another external expert advised hospital executives that surgery should cease, labeling the persistent high mortality as a red-flag indicator of systemic failure. Following this advice, the liver and pancreatic surgery department was shut down. Based on the 2022 fatality calculations, Habib suggested that many more patients may have died unnecessarily. He claimed to have contacted the police, government ministers, and the independent whistleblowing officer multiple times, but was often told the cases were time-barred.
These allegations are the latest in a series of crises at NHS Grampian, which has already seen the shutdown of pediatric surgery at Gray’s Hospital and the replacement of key leadership positions. Health Secretary Angela Constance recently told lawmakers that the board faces extremely serious systemic problems. She warned that the health board could be placed into special measures if current reforms are not implemented effectively and quickly.
A report by Healthcare Improvement Scotland found very serious shortcomings in the board's leadership, including a lack of transparency. However, that report only identified one patient death due to a serious adverse event. Habib and Anwar argue that the expert review of their specific unit shows many more avoidable deaths, raising concerns that the full extent of the crisis is being obscured. Anwar urged the Lord Advocate to instruct Police Scotland to launch a criminal investigation and for ministers to place the board into special measures immediately.
A Scottish government spokesperson acknowledged the courage of the whistleblower and stated that ministers had repeatedly raised the concerns with NHS Grampian and the healthcare watchdog. The government noted that the board is currently subject to a significant level of intervention and support. They added that any criminal investigation would be a matter for Police Scotland, who have been approached for comment.






