Aria and Writers Guild Reject AI Permit Model Favoring Music
Industry leaders warn a government proposal to exempt musicians from AI scraping rules would fracture the creative sector and fail to protect other copyright holders.
By Tyler Wood ·

The Australian Recording Industry Association and the Australian Writers’ Guild rejected a reported proposal to exempt musicians from new AI scraping rules, arguing that a carveout for one sector would leave other creatives vulnerable. The two groups said the plan, which would allow AI companies to buy permits to train on Australian data, effectively pits creative workers against one another.
The Australian Financial Review reported on Thursday that the Albanese government was weighing a copyright change. Under this framework, AI firms would purchase licenses to access Australian content. However, the report suggested that music might be shielded from these requirements. This structure aligns with models proposed by Anthropic and OpenAI. Anthropic suggested a system of conditional approval where scraping is allowed unless a rightsholder objects. OpenAI told a parliamentary committee it would potentially support a fund for creators.
The debate over AI and copyright has intensified over the past two years. In 2024, industry representatives began working with the government to develop a licensing model. They stated that tech companies have refused to engage in those negotiations for several years. This week, the creative community launched a major campaign focused on AI regulation. Senior ministers have recently signaled that current copyright laws need reform.
Annabelle Herd, CEO of Aria, and Claire Pullen, CEO of the Australian Writers’ Guild, said the community would remain united against the proposal. Herd stated she was unaware of the specific plan before Thursday’s report. She argued that if the industry had been consulted, it would have called the scheme unnecessary and unworkable. Pullen noted that the proposal creates technical difficulties. She questioned how to handle mixed media content, such as films that combine music, video, and scripts, if only one element is exempt from scraping rules.
"Had we been consulted, we would have advised this scheme is unnecessary, unworkable and designed to suit the commercial interests of AI companies, not protect creators," Herd said. "Our position is unchanged: we stand with the rest of the creative and media industries."
The Media, Entertainment & Arts Alliance described itself as alarmed by the report. The group demanded that the protections promised by Prime Minister Anthony Albanese apply to all creative sectors, not just music. Albanese has previously called the use of creative work without payment theft. He stated that artists need compensation for their labor.
The government has not commented on the specific details of the proposal. However, senior ministers have used stronger language regarding copyright shortfalls in the AI era. Industry Minister Tim Ayres said on Tuesday that the status quo is no good for creative workers. Acting Prime Minister Richard Marles repeated this sentiment on Thursday, adding on News24 that people are being ripped off.
Attorney General Michelle Rowland’s office promised certainty and strong protections for Australian artists. A spokesperson said the work of Australian creatives is currently being used without consent or payment. The government will continue to advocate for commercial deals between tech firms and artists.
Parliamentary figures across the political spectrum criticized the idea of a music-specific exemption. Shadow Attorney General Michaelia Cash said the proposal would divide rightsholders. She argued that everyone who owns property should have the same right to prevent it from being stolen. Greens Senator Sarah Hanson-Young warned that allowing such a loophole would make Australia the Cayman Islands for AI.
David Pocock described the plan as a divide and conquer strategy. He noted that the joint select committee has not yet delivered its report to the government. He expressed confusion over the government’s current strategy while various whispers circulate about its planning. The creative sector maintains that it has offered solutions since 2024, but technology companies have declined to negotiate.
More Business · Business Complaints · Report a business · Got a Story?





